Evolution Q&A (With Pictures).

I just responded to a private message about evolution, religion and so on and decided to copy two evolution bits into a blog because I thought they were interesting.  Hope you enjoy and perhaps find them rec’-worthy:

“The problem that I have with macroevolution is jumping from one species to an entirely different species (i.e. reptile to bird or whatnot).”

First off, birds descended from dinosaurs which descended from reptiles. And second, there are no “entirely different” species. A bird has more or less the same digestive, respiratory, reproductive, nervous etc systems as you do, with not that much variation. And the differences in scale between a human and a bird are what can easily be seen within the same species like so.

Furthermore even the most significant differences diagnostic of differentiating birds from humans and even mammals like having feathers also indicate common ancestry, because the same DNA that makes a bird’s feathers also makes a reptile’s scales and claws, and your hair (and claws), and hair (fur), scales, feathers, claws, calluses etc are all made of the same material, one of two variations of a chemical called keratin. We give live birth and they lay eggs, but we inherited our placenta from reptiles just as birds did. There are far, far more similarities between most animals than there are differences, the idea of an “entirely new” species is a superficial one.[Edit: And I should’ve mentioned also studies have shown that a gene that is vital for songbirds to be able to sing, when altered, causes speech problems in humans – if I were a biologist I’m sure I could go on all day with this stuff.  I believe the appropriate internet parlance would be “evolution FTW”.]

“With the lack of transitionary fossils showing such changes I find it very unlikely.”

There are assloads of transitional fossils. We can track whales back to when they walked on land (and some still retain hip bones):

we can track horses back to when they had multiple toes

“(and when birds had digits on their “wings” and even feathers but no wings).”


“We can trace bats to when they had no sonar, we can trace snakes back to lizards (some snakes still retain vestigial legs to this day), we can get fossilized single-celled organisms out of rocks and see how they evolved over billions of years:

We can trace turtles back to when they couldn’t retract into their shells and had armored tails and teeth:

and before they even had full shells, just armor on their bellies and partial upper shells:

Or when monsters like this roamed the ocean:


We have transitional fossils between every major group, amphibians to reptiles, reptiles to mammals, reptiles to dinosaurs and dinosaurs to birds etc. Honestly, what kind of transitional form are you in the market for?


About agnophilo

This entry was posted in Uncategorized and tagged , , , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

6 Responses to Evolution Q&A (With Pictures).

  1. bosefius says:

    LIESSSS!!!!! Your theory is wrong, it’s just a theory!!!Sorry, someone had to say it and I wanted to steal their thunder. I liked it, thank you.

  2. agnophilo says:

    @bosefius – Actually in the full PM the person did pull the “just a theory” line.@Kristenmomof3 – : )  Btw responding to julie would be good.

  3. bosefius says:

    @agnophilo – See, I know how this game is played. The first step is to remove any understanding of science…

  4. I see you’ve provided a fossil to fill in the gap I pointed out. Silly scientist, now there are TWO gaps!

Speak yer mind.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s